Island Nations (SIDS) vs. Scuba Diving

Island Nations (SIDS) and Scuba Diving

Island Nations (SIDS) vs. Scuba Diving

A Dive Into the Social, Economic & Environmental Costs of Dive Tourism in Island Communities

When we go on vacation to a tropical island, we see a paradise. But can we ensure that we are not making life hell for the local population? How does dive tourism fit into a sustainable Blue Economy for small island nations that are currently facing severe social, economic, and environmental threats?

I read a few research papers, primarily authored by Zahidah Afrin Nisa, that explore the critical intersection of the scuba diving industry and the sustainable development of Small Island Developing States (SIDS), particularly concerning coral reef ecosystems. I’m sharing my personal observations and understanding of the topics.

Zahidah Afrin Nisa and her co-authors analyze gaps in current science-policy interfaces and advocate for stronger collaborations between governments, the scuba diving industry, and scientific communities to address issues like workforce development, safety standards, and the sustainable use of marine resources

They also examine revenue leakage, the extent to which dive tourism revenues leave the island instead of contributing to the sustainable development of its Blue Economy.

They ultimately aim for a more resilient and equitable blue economy in island nations.

This post is part of our Blueprints 4.0 for a Healthier Dive Industry Business Model series by the Business of Diving Institute and Darcy Kieran, author of:

Imagine this: you’re chilling on a beautiful tropical island, crystal clear water, colorful fish everywhere – paradise, right? Well, a big part of what makes these islands tick economically is tourism, and a super fun and economically significant slice of that is scuba diving. People travel from all over the world to strap on scuba cylinders and explore those amazing underwater worlds.

Scuba diving around coral reefs to see cool marine life is a huge money-maker globally – we’re talking billions of dollars a year. And guess who often has the most stunning coral reefs and marine critters? You got it, those beautiful island nations we were just imagining. In some places, scuba diving tourism can bring in as much money as or even more than fishing! That’s a big deal for their economies.

But here’s the catch: it can be like buying a souvenir from a local artisan on vacation and then realizing most of your money went to a big company somewhere else – maybe it was “Made in China.”

In our case, for instance, while dive training agencies provide standards and training, a significant chunk of the money tourists spend – for courses, certifications, memberships of the instructor and dive center, insurance, and the like – goes to these outside corporations.

From our Porter’s Five Forces analysis of the scuba diving industry, we already know that dive training agencies grab an inordinate percentage of the scuba diving experience value chain.

Zaidy and her colleagues highlight the necessity of integrating the diving sector, including its workforce and economic contributions, into blue economy strategies and policy frameworks to achieve the United Nations (UN) Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), especially SDG 8 (Decent Work) and SDG 14 (Life Below Water). Part of their goal is for small island nations to keep more of the tourism dollars at home to reinvest in themselves.

This is where a national or regional “Blue Economy” plan comes in. Think of it as island nations trying to make the most of their ocean resources in a sustainable way. This requires developing a skilled local workforce instead of hiring expatriates. For these islands to thrive, especially with beautiful but fragile coral reefs, they need more of that scuba diving tourism money to stay on the island.

That money can then be reinvested right back into the things that matter for their Blue Economy. We’re talking about things like:

  • Protecting and restoring their precious coral reefs. Healthy reefs mean more amazing diving, which brings more tourists! It’s a win-win.
  • Building better and safer infrastructure for the diving industry, like hyperbaric chambers in case of diving accidents, and supporting local dive businesses.
  • Training local people to be top-notch dive guides, instructors, and marine conservationists creates good jobs and ensures the expertise stays local.
  • Developing sustainable tourism practices that benefit both the environment and the local communities.

In a nutshell, it’s about empowering island nations to be the primary beneficiaries of their stunning underwater attractions. They need to figure out ways to keep more of the scuba diving dollars flowing into their own economies instead of seeing too much of it swim away to companies and individuals elsewhere like dive professionals coming in for short periods and leaving with all their earnings.

That way, island nations can invest in a healthy ocean and a prosperous future – their very own Blue Economy. It’s like saying, “Hey, these are our amazing reefs, and we should be able to use the income from showing them off to build a better future for our islands!”

You may also be interested in:

…and the following podcast episode about our take on Small Island Developing States (SIDS) vs. Scuba Diving:

If you found the information on this page valuable, would you consider buying me a coffee?

Either way, let’s work together on “raising the bar” in the dive industry to satisfy today’s consumers!

Your Dive Industry Compass

Scuba Diving Market Research, Surveys, Reports & Statistics

Blueprints 4.0: A Healthier Business Model

Scuba Diving Industry Structure, Competitive Analysis, Business Models & Strategies for Growth With The New Scuba Diver

Living The Scuba Dream

Plan Your Scuba Instructor Career & Deep Dive the Plan

You may also be interested in The Immersion Zone (our podcast), Scubanomics (our newsletter for dive professionals), and our published books & reference guides.